Skip to main content

As vehicle technology continues to evolve, artificial intelligence is playing a larger role in how some vehicles operate. Advanced driver assistance systems can help with steering, braking, acceleration, lane positioning, and other driving functions. More advanced automated driving systems are also being tested and deployed in certain locations.

But what happens when a vehicle operating with automated technology causes a crash?

If there is no human actively controlling the vehicle, determining who may be responsible for the resulting injuries can become more complicated than a traditional car accident. Potentially responsible parties could include a vehicle owner, driver, manufacturer, software developer, operator, or another company involved in the automated driving system.

The answer depends on the technology involved, how the vehicle was being operated, what caused the accident, and the laws that apply to the crash.

What Is an Autonomous Vehicle?

The term “autonomous vehicle” can describe several different levels of vehicle automation, but not all automated technology means that a vehicle is driving itself.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, or NHTSA, distinguishes between driver assistance systems and automated driving systems. Level 2 systems can assist with both steering and acceleration or braking, but the human driver remains responsible for monitoring the vehicle and driving environment. More advanced Levels 3 through 5 involve increasing levels of automation, with Level 4 systems capable of handling the driving task within defined conditions without requiring a human driver.

That distinction matters after a collision.

For example, a driver who was using a vehicle’s lane-centering and adaptive cruise control features may still have significant responsibility for operating the vehicle. In contrast, an accident involving a driverless vehicle operating within an approved service area may raise very different questions about responsibility.

NHTSA currently states that fully automated, self-driving vehicles are not available for sale to consumers in the United States. However, autonomous vehicles are being tested and deployed in certain circumstances, including driverless operations in California.

Who Could Be Responsible for an Autonomous Vehicle Accident?

There is no single rule that automatically makes the vehicle manufacturer responsible when an autonomous vehicle crashes.

Instead, investigators may need to determine what went wrong and which party, if any, was legally responsible.

Potentially responsible parties may include:

The Human Driver

If a human driver was expected to monitor the vehicle, the driver’s actions could still be relevant. A driver may potentially be responsible if they failed to follow instructions, ignored warnings, failed to take control when required, or otherwise operated the vehicle negligently.

This is particularly important with Level 2 driver assistance systems. Although the technology may control steering and acceleration or braking, NHTSA states that the driver remains responsible for the driving task.

The Vehicle Manufacturer

A manufacturer could potentially face liability if a vehicle or one of its components was defective and that defect contributed to the accident.

For example, an investigation could examine whether a hardware failure, sensor problem, braking defect, or other vehicle-related issue contributed to a collision.

The Automated Driving System Developer

An autonomous vehicle depends on sophisticated software, sensors, cameras, artificial intelligence, and other technology to perceive its surroundings and make driving decisions.

If a defect or failure in an automated driving system contributed to an accident, the company responsible for developing or supplying that system could potentially become part of the liability investigation.

NHTSA has authority to investigate safety defects involving automated driving systems and other vehicle technologies. The agency also requires certain manufacturers and operators to report qualifying crashes involving automated driving systems and certain Level 2 advanced driver assistance systems.

A Fleet Operator Or Autonomous Vehicle Company

Some autonomous vehicles operate as part of commercial fleets rather than being privately owned.

If a company owns, operates, maintains, or remotely supervises a vehicle, questions may arise about whether something the company did or failed to do contributed to the accident.

Maintenance, vehicle deployment, operating conditions, remote assistance, and compliance with applicable requirements may all become relevant depending on the circumstances.

Multiple Parties

An autonomous vehicle accident may not necessarily have one responsible party.

A crash could involve a combination of factors. For example, a software problem could contribute to an unsafe maneuver while a separate mechanical defect affects the vehicle’s ability to stop. A human operator’s actions could also be relevant.

Determining responsibility may therefore require looking at the entire chain of events rather than focusing solely on the fact that artificial intelligence was controlling the vehicle.

How Is Fault Determined?

Determining responsibility after an autonomous vehicle accident can require evidence that is different from what investigators typically examine after a traditional crash.

Evidence may include:

  • Vehicle data and event recordings
  • Sensor and camera information
  • Automated driving system logs
  • Software and system information
  • Vehicle maintenance records
  • Accident reports
  • Witness statements
  • Video from nearby vehicles or businesses
  • Information about whether automated technology was engaged
  • Communications between the vehicle and a remote operator, when applicable
  • Information about the vehicle’s operating conditions

This evidence can help establish what the vehicle was doing immediately before the collision and whether an automated system was operating at the time.

NHTSA notes that automated driving systems can have extensive data-recording and telemetry capabilities, although the amount and availability of information can vary between vehicles and systems.

What About California?

California has established a regulatory framework for autonomous vehicle testing and deployment, and those rules continue to evolve as the technology develops.

In April 2026, the California Department of Motor Vehicles announced updated autonomous vehicle regulations covering light-duty and heavy-duty vehicles. The regulations include additional safety requirements, data reporting provisions, collision reporting requirements, and oversight of autonomous vehicle operations.

California also maintains information about autonomous vehicle permit holders and collision reports. The DMV currently authorizes certain manufacturers to test autonomous vehicles without a safety driver under specified conditions.

These regulations govern how autonomous vehicles can be tested and deployed, but they do not mean that every accident involving an autonomous vehicle automatically makes the manufacturer liable for injuries.

Civil liability is a separate question that depends on the facts of the particular accident and applicable law.

What About Arizona?

Arizona also has laws that specifically address certain situations involving fully autonomous vehicles.

For example, Arizona statutes include provisions addressing accident-related duties when a fully autonomous vehicle is operating without a human driver. The law recognizes circumstances in which the vehicle owner or someone acting on the owner’s behalf fulfills certain accident-related responsibilities.

The existence of these provisions illustrates an important point: laws governing autonomous vehicles can differ from traditional traffic laws and can vary by state.

As autonomous vehicle technology develops, state laws and regulations may continue to change.

Why The Technology Level Matters After a Crash

One of the first questions after an accident involving automated technology may be surprisingly simple:

Was the vehicle actually driving itself?

A vehicle marketed with terms such as “autopilot,” “driver assistance,” or “automated driving” may still require a human driver to remain attentive and responsible for driving.

That is why identifying the specific technology involved can be critical.

An accident involving a driver-assistance feature may raise different legal questions than an accident involving a driverless vehicle. The name used to describe the technology is not necessarily enough to determine who was responsible.

What Should You Do After an Autonomous Vehicle Accident?

If you are injured in a collision involving an autonomous or highly automated vehicle, obtaining information about the vehicle and technology involved may be important.

As with any serious accident, medical attention should be a priority. It can also be helpful to preserve photographs, videos, witness information, accident reports, and other available evidence.

If possible, information about the vehicle itself can also be important. This may include the make and model, whether the vehicle was part of an autonomous fleet, and whether an automated driving system was operating when the crash occurred.

Because autonomous vehicle technology can generate information that may not be visible to someone at the scene, preserving and investigating available evidence can be especially important.

The Future of Autonomous Vehicle Liability

Autonomous vehicles have the potential to change the way people travel, but they also raise new questions about responsibility when something goes wrong.

As vehicles take on more of the driving task, the traditional question of “Who was driving?” may become only one part of a much larger investigation.

Future cases could require courts and investigators to examine software, sensors, artificial intelligence, vehicle design, human oversight, maintenance, remote operations, and other factors when determining responsibility for an accident.

For now, the law continues to develop alongside the technology. NHTSA has acknowledged that liability and insurance are among the issues policymakers must address as automated driving systems mature.

If you are injured in an accident involving an autonomous vehicle or advanced driving technology, understanding what happened and identifying the parties involved can be an important part of evaluating your options.

How Fielding Law Can Help

At Fielding Law, we understand that every personal injury case involves its own circumstances, evidence, and legal considerations. When a collision involves emerging vehicle technology, understanding how the accident happened may require looking beyond the traditional driver-versus-driver analysis.

Our personal injury attorneys represent people injured in motor vehicle accidents and can help evaluate the circumstances surrounding an injury and explain potential legal options.

If you have been injured in an accident involving an autonomous or automated vehicle, call 833.88.SHARK. for a free, no-obligation consultation, available 24/7. Fielding Law is here to help you understand your options and take the next step forward.

Fielding Law, APC – Irvine, CA Office
505 Technology Dr Ste 250
Irvine, CA 92618
(949) 288-5484


Fielding Law, APC – Phoenix, AZ Office
2 N Central Ave Ste 1800
Phoenix, AZ 85004
(859) 578-4444

Note: Information provided is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult with a qualified attorney for legal concerns.

BLOG HOME